Sometimes, when we talk to patients who have cancer, we say the wrong thing, over and over and over. We tell them they’re in the midst of a battle, or a war. We tell them they can beat it if they fight it, if they’re strong, if they never give up.
But what if all the pain, suffering, and indignity they’ve endured in chemotherapy has left them wanting to close their eyes and rest peacefully in the knowledge that their time has come? Urging them to fight is not going to make them feel better. It might make them feel worse — as if they did not try hard enough and failed.
“There’s better healing language that can be used,” says Katie Deming, MD. “But it’s going to be different for everyone.”
Dr. Deming is a radiation oncologist and former medical director of cancer services for Kaiser Permanente in Portland, Oregon. She wants to change the way we talk to patients with cancer. Specifically, she wants to give the patients a voice in how we discuss their illness. She recently gave a TEDx talk in Reno, Nevada, titled How to Talk to Someone With Cancer.
About a decade ago, Dr. Deming and her colleagues surveyed 1,400 patients who had breast cancer to share their feelings about the term “cancer survivor.” She wasn’t prepared for the results: 60% of the respondents considered the term “survivor” to be negative. Patients said it didn’t accurately reflect their unique experience of cancer. Others felt as if they were tempting fate to say they’d “survived.” Some expressed anger, saying they had stage 4 cancer and that survival wasn’t likely.
“This made me really pay attention to the language I used,” Dr. Deming said recently. “And when I started looking more closely, I realized we tend to use a lot of battle language, like ‘Win the fight.’ I also noticed that these terms were not helping my patients.”
When it comes to cancer, most of us rely on language that suggests “fighting” means it can be “beaten,” a comforting sentiment that puts off unpleasant thoughts about death and provides a sense that the illness is temporary and soon everything will be back to normal.
But it can mean something else entirely for the patient. Some may feel compelled to give chemotherapy or other treatments another try because they don’t want to “give up the fight” and disappoint their family when they’d really rather accept their mortality and die on their own terms. Using the language of the battlefield doesn’t motivate these patients. In fact, in some cases it may increase cortisol levels and anxiety and weaken the immune system. Rather than being calming and supportive, this language could aggravate their suffering.
So, Deming is trying to start a different conversation and it starts by putting the patients’ needs first. And to find out what exactly the patient needs, the best start is to ask them.
“It’s ok to say, ‘I want you to know I’m here for you and I want to know what’s most supportive for you.’”
When Dr. Deming asked a close family member with breast cancer how she could be most supportive, her relative said she loved to see photos of house pets. So, rather than daily texts that put the onus on the patient – How are you? – Dr. Deming sent along photos of her pets.
They were a big hit — which isn’t surprising. Laughing at a cat chasing its own tail is a nice respite from “fighting for your life.”
Donna Budway received prompt surgery followed by chemotherapy. She credits …
Kaiser Permanente in San Diego helped plan a special send-off for Katie …
Shannon Parkin survived 7 suicide attempts. She shares her story of hope …
Our investment in the Watts neighborhood of California, in partnership …
The Kaiser Permanente Colorado Health Action Summit gathered nonprofits, …
A Kaiser Permanente doctor shares key details. By learning more about autism, …
Funding from Kaiser Permanente in Washington helps to promote mental health, …
Exceptional, personalized radiation oncology care helped Maura Craig treat …
Chris Hogan faced kidney cancer and prostate cancer at the same time. He …
Participate in a study to help uncover the causes of cancer and how to …
A young father is enjoying “bonus time” with his kids thanks to new targeted …
Patients like Carol Pitman are living longer thanks to advances in lung …
Behavioral health consultants can provide a better understanding of often …
Feeling emotional or overwhelmed after a new baby’s arrival? You’re not …
Kaiser Permanente has opened a new Radiation Oncology Center at the Bellflower …
After a lifetime of feeling isolated, Moth Wygal finds connection thanks …
Naomi Girma, a sports ambassador for Kaiser Permanente, is passionate about …
Some of the most common conditions affecting men carry a social stigma …
One in 5 people experience depression, anxiety, or other mental health …
Lynch syndrome is a gene mutation that increases colon cancer risk. Learn …
A healthy life after cancer is possible. Learn how Kaiser Permanente helps …
As part of the Cancer Screening Research Network, our researchers will …
A timely preventive test reveals Rebecca Kucera has cancer. Swift treatment …
Early detection of the disease, before it becomes advanced, will increase …
Screening for colorectal cancer is recommended for most people starting …
Gabriel Abarca had no hope for his future. Then the team at Kaiser Permanente …
Innovative surgical recovery program helps breast cancer patients safely …
The Kaiser Permanente Watts Counseling and Learning Center started as a …
Kaiser Permanente supports the ballot measure to expand and improve mental …
You have only one heart. ‘Prescribe’ yourself a few changes to help protect …
Kaiser Permanente opens medical offices and a new home for the Watts Counselin …
Supporting behavioral and mental health in communities where needs are …
Grateful for compassionate and successful Hodgkin lymphoma treatment at …
Better public policies can help address the challenges. We encourage policymak …
Kaiser Permanente’s Patient Advisory Councils help us create exceptional …
There aren’t enough mental health professionals in the U.S. to meet the …
Cervical cancer is highly preventable. Learn how HPV vaccination and regular …
An unexpected cancer diagnosis left Jennifer Martin unsure of the next …
We offer housing-related legal help to prevent evictions and remove barriers …
Learn how you can participate in a study to uncover what causes cancer …
From diagnosis to recovery, David Parsons, MD, shares how screening, treatment …
Pavan Somusetty, MD, explains how people who need support and guidance …
As a lifelong nonsmoker, Mariann Stephens was shocked to learn she had …
Six steps help you prep for winter trips.
A team of specialists treats an expecting mother’s cancer while keeping …
A child and adolescent psychiatrist shares tips on supporting your child …
Joy Short, a Kaiser Permanente member and employee, turned her breast cancer …
For 75-year-old Peggy Dickston, a surprise diagnosis was caught early thanks …
Kaiser Permanente’s partnership with Fontana Unified School District brings …
Use biofeedback to help manage stress.
Former Major League Baseball player Drew Robinson shares his story of hope …
San Diego Wave Fútbol Club star defender Naomi Girma, Kaiser Permanente …
Our clinicians help patients get the care they need to move forward with …
Kaiser Permanente increases access to mental health services in Southern …
Expanding access to high-quality mental health services
Stories in the Department of Research & Evaluation 2022 Annual Report demonstr …
Research and clinical trials play a vital role in advancing cancer treatment …
Kaiser Permanente is at the forefront of cervical cancer research. Find …
Mammograms can help detect breast cancer early, when it’s easier to treat. …
After a diagnosis for a rare type of blood cancer, Marla Marriott got high-qua …
These tips from Don Mordecai, MD, Kaiser Permanente’s national mental health …
Learn how lifestyle medicine is part of cancer care at Kaiser Permanente.
Fay Gordon's breast cancer was caught in the early stages thanks to genetic …
Chemotherapy can be an option during pregnancy. Find out how Kaiser Permanente …
Michael West shares his incredible journey from diagnosis to treatment …
A Kaiser Permanente plastic surgeon explains breast reconstruction options …
Many people with cancer experience depression and anxiety. Mental health …
After they were both diagnosed with colon cancer, Miguel and Paula fought …
Unique challenges and societal pressures can impact men’s emotional well-being …
Age, family history, and race are key factors.
Doctor and mother of 3 Susan Brim received top-notch care after her lung …
Kaiser Permanente and the San Diego Wave Fútbol Club host a second Wave …
Carter Shaver from Portland, Oregon, shares his optimistic smile after …
Kaiser Permanente is here to help with care and valuable tools to support …
Help change the future of cancer prevention by joining Connect today.
A new study compares Kaiser Permanente members in Southern California to …
Take time to adjust to a new baby and lifestyle changes — and reach out …
Tips for preventing sunburn and decreasing the risk of skin cancer.
Thanks to personalized care from a team of skilled doctors, Christina McAmis …
Shared experience helps young people in Oregon build confidence for their …
Creating a healthy relationship with social media can help safeguard the …
A Kaiser Permanente member shares his personal journey of navigating bipolar …
Changing my career and becoming a therapist revealed ways our country can …
Peer mentoring program matches new cancer patients with others who’ve gone …
Susan Sandhu struggled to find meaning in her life after an injury forced …
Trauma-informed outreach efforts in Orange County are being recognized …
Expanded access to high-quality, affordable mental health care supports …
Child psychiatrist defines anxiety, its symptoms, how to address it, and …
As a nonsmoker, Betty Schuldt’s stage 4 lung cancer diagnosis was surprising, …
When thousands of women industrial workers, often called “Rosies,” joined …
Kaiser Permanente’s partnership with Special Olympics Southern California …
Treatment for bipolar disorder and opiate addiction helps a Kaiser Permanente …
A new study invites participants in Oregon to help uncover what causes …
Southern California psychiatrist offers practical advice for parents to …
Learn why early screening is crucial for prevention and treatment.
Kaiser Permanente in Southern California partners with San Diego Wave Fútbol …
Kaiser Permanente provides members with convenient ways to improve their …
A sleep expert shares 4 practical tips for coping with the time shift and …
Project Nurture in Portland, Oregon, provides treatment and a path forward …
Expert shares 5 valuable tips for parents and guardians to help children …